Ministers’ Deputies
    Annotated Agenda

    CM/Del/OJ/DH(2009)1059 Addendum 27 May 20091
    Preparation of the next meeting

    ———————————————

    1059th meeting (DH), 2-4 and 5 (morning) June 2009

    c. Preparation of the next DH meeting
    1065th meeting (DH), 15-16 September 2009

    Preliminary draft agenda


    ——————————————

    Action

    The Deputies are invited to approve the preliminary draft agenda for their 1065th meeting (DH), 15-16 September 2009, as it appears below.

    Please note that the lists for certain groups of cases appear in separate Appendices, which are available from links.

    In accordance with the examination system established for Human Rights meetings, the Deputies are invited to take note of the following schedule for the issue of documents for the 1065th DH meeting (15-16 September 2009):

    a. a list of new items for consideration at the 1065th meeting will be issued in the “Preliminary list of items for consideration at the 1065th meeting”;

    b. Delegations wishing to provide information concerning the items appearing on the preliminary agenda for the 1065th meeting are invited to make such information available to the Secretariat before 1 July 2009;

    c. in principle, new judgments of the Court for which the Secretariat has received confirmation that they are final on or before 1 July 2009, will be added and Section 2 (together with the draft decisions) will be placed on the Committee of Ministers’ Internet site on 18 August 2009;

    d. Sections 4.1 (together with the draft decisions) and 4.3 (together with the draft decisions), will be placed on the Committee of Ministers’ Internet site on 25 August 2009;

    e. the order of business will be placed on the Committee of Ministers’ Internet site on 2 September 2009;

    f. Sections 4.2, 5, 6, 1 and General Questions (together with the draft decisions), will be placed on the Committee of Ministers’ Internet site on 8 September 2009, and the accompanying addenda will be distributed shortly afterwards.

    DRAFT DECISIONS

    Item c. Preparation of the next meeting (DH)
    (1065th meeting, 15-16 September 2009)

    Decisions

    The Deputies,

    1. approved the preliminary draft Agenda of their 1065th meeting (15-16 September 2009 (DH)), as it appears below;

    2. approved the following time-table for the preparation of the meeting:

    a. a list of new items for consideration at the 1065th meeting will be issued in the “Preliminary list of items for consideration at the 1065th meeting”;

    b. Delegations wishing to provide information concerning the items appearing on the preliminary agenda for the 1065th meeting are invited to make such information available to the Secretariat before 1 July 2009;

    c. in principle, new judgments of the Court for which the Secretariat has received confirmation that they are final on or before 1 July 2009, will be added and Section 2 (together with the draft decisions) will be placed on the Committee of Ministers’ Internet site on 18 August 2009;

    d. Sections 4.1 (together with the draft decisions) and 4.3 (together with the draft decisions), will be placed on the Committee of Ministers’ Internet site on 25 August 2009;

    e. the order of business will be placed on the Committee of Ministers’ Internet site on 2 September 2009;

    f. Sections 4.2, 5, 6, 1 and General Questions (together with the draft decisions), will be placed on the Committee of Ministers’ Internet site on 8 September 2009, and the accompanying addenda will be distributed shortly afterwards.

    CONTENTS

    GENERAL QUESTIONS 5

    SECTION 1 - FINAL RESOLUTIONS 6

    SECTION 2 - NEW CASES 8

    SECTION 3 - JUST SATISFACTION 25

    SECTION 4 - CASES RAISING SPECIFIC QUESTIONS (INDIVIDUAL MEASURES, MEASURES NOT YET DEFINED OR SPECIAL PROBLEMS) 26

    SECTION 5 - SUPERVISION OF GENERAL MEASURES ALREADY ANNOUNCED 37

    SECTION 6 - CASES PRESENTED WITH A VIEW TO THE PREPARATION OF A DRAFT FINAL RESOLUTION 42

    Additional documents

    Addendum General Questions
    Addendum 1 - Final Resolutions
    Addendum Preparation of the next DH meeting (1072nd meeting (1-3 and 4 (morning) December 2009))

    GENERAL QUESTIONS

    Item a.

    Adoption of the Annotated Agenda and Order of Business

    Action
    The Deputies are invited to adopt the annotated agenda and the Order of Business.

    Item b.

    State of ratification by member states of the European Agreement relating to persons participating in proceedings of the European Court of human rights, the Sixth Protocol to the General Agreement on privileges and immunities of the Council of Europe and Protocols No 6, No. 12, No. 13, No. 14 and 14 bis to the Convention for the protection of human rights and fundamental freedoms

    Action
    The Deputies are invited to provide information on the state of signature and ratification of these texts. Tables showing the current state of signature and ratification appear in Addendum General Questions.

    Item c.

    Preparation of the next meeting (1072nd meeting (1-3 and 4 (morning) December 2009)
    See Addendum Preparation of the next meeting

    Action
    The Deputies are invited to approve the preliminary draft Agenda of their 1072nd meeting (1-3 and 4 (morning) December 2009), as it appears in Addendum Preparation of the next meeting, together with the time-table for the preparation of the meeting.

    Item d.

    Measures to improve the execution of the judgments of the European Court of Human Rights

    Action
    The Deputies are invited to resume consideration of this item.

    SECTION 1 - FINAL RESOLUTIONS

    (Addendum 1)

    Action

    The Deputies are invited to adopt the resolutions putting and end to the examination of the following cases as they appear in Addendum 1.

    SUB-SECTION 1.1 – LEADING CASES

    No new case

    SUB-SECTION 1.2 – CASES CONCERNING PROBLEMS ALREADY SOLVED

    No new case

    SUB-SECTION 1.3 – CASES NOT INVOLVING GENERAL OR INDIVIDUAL MEASURES

    No new case

    SUB-SECTION 1.4 – FRIENDLY SETTLEMENTS AND PROBLEMS OF A GENERAL CHARACTER

    No new case

    SECTION 2 - NEW CASES

    This section lists the new judgments rendered by the European Court of Human Rights, (for further details, see the texts of the judgments on http://www.echr.coe.int).

    Action

    The Deputies are invited to take a decision to resume consideration of these cases following expiry of the date-limit set by the Court for payment of the just satisfaction or, depending on the requirements of the cases, on completion of bilateral consultations between the Secretariat and the delegations concerned.

    Payment of just satisfaction

    In all new cases in which states are obliged to pay a sum, whether granted by the Court or agreed to in friendly settlement, the authorities of the state concerned are invited to provide written confirmation of payment to the Secretariat.

    General or individual measures

    The general and/or individual measures required are currently under consideration in the context of bilateral consultations.

    However, in all cases circulation of the text of the judgment to the competent authorities is required and delegations are invited to provide written confirmation of this.

    The cases for which the final character of the judgment has not yet been confirmed by the Court appear on a grey background.

    The Deputies decided in particular to resume consideration of these items at their 1072nd meeting (1-3 and 4 (morning) December 2009) (DH), in the light of information to be provided on the payment of the just satisfaction, if necessary.

    - 1 case against Albania

    19206/05 Dauti, judgment of 03/02/2009, final on 03/05/2009

    - 6 cases against Armenia

    31237/03 Kirakosyan, judgment of 02/12/2008, final on 04/05/2009
    22390/05 Mkhitaryan, judgment of 02/12/2008, final on 04/05/2009
    41698/04 Tadevosyan, judgment of 02/12/2008, final on 04/05/2009

    - Cases concerning the right of freedom of assembly
    31553/03 Amiryan, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
    35944/03 Gasparyan No. 1, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
    35738/03 Sapeyan, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009

    - 5 cases against Austria

    49686/99 Gütl, judgment of 12/03/2009, final on 12/06/2009
    28648/03 Lang, judgment of 19/03/2009, final on 19/06/2009
    42967/98 Löffelman, judgment of 12/03/2009, final on 12/06/2009

    - Case concerning freedom of religion
    76581/01 Verein der Freunde der Christengemeinschaft and others, judgment of 26/02/2009, final on 26/05/2005

      - Case concerning the length of proceedings concerning civil rights and obligations before administrative courts and / or the lack of an oral hearing

    33928/05 Klug, judgment of 15/01/2009, final on 15/04/2009

    - 6 cases against Belgium

    44256/06 Cakir Turan, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009

    45413/07 Anakomba Yula, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009

    49230/07 L’Erablière A.S.B.L., judgment of 19/02/2009, final on 19/05/2009

    22945/07 Houtman and Meeus, judgment of 17/03/2009, final on 17/06/2009

    - Cases of length of judicial proceedings and of lack of an effective remedy
    44807/06 Poelmans, judgment of 03/02/2009, final on 03/05/2009
    35327/05 Leonardi, judgment of 03/02/2009, final on 03/05/2009

    - 2 cases against Bosnia and Herzegovina

      - Case concerning the failure or substantial delay by the administration in abiding by final domestic judgments concerning old savings denominated in foreign currency

    38945/05 Pralica, judgment of 27/01/2009, final on 27/04/2009

      - Case concerning the failure or substantial delay by the administration in abiding by final decision of the Human Rights Chamber

    7435/04 Milisavljević, judgment of 03/03/2009, final on 03/06/2009

    - 17 cases against Bulgaria

      - Case mainly concerning deaths or ill-treatment which took place under the responsibility of the forces of order

    31365/02 Dimitrov Georgi, judgment of 15/01/2009, final on 15/04/2009

    37449/02 Shishmanov, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009

    3991/03 Bulves Ad, judgment of 22/01/2009, final on 22/04/2009

      - Cases concerning the violation of the applicants' right to the peaceful enjoyment of their possessions due to the annulment of their title to property acquired under the communist regime

    56753/00 Dimitar and Anka Dimitrovi, judgment of 12/02/2009, final on 12/05/2009
    57176/00 Koprinarovi, judgment of 15/01/2009, final on 15/04/2009
    6189/03 Mihaylovi, judgment of 12/02/2009, final on 12/05/2009
    60805/00 Miteva, judgment of 12/02/2009, final on 12/05/2009
    55722/00 Simova and Georgiev, judgment of 12/02/2009, final on 12/05/2009
    42617/02 Vladimirova and others, judgment of 26/02/2009, final on 26/05/2005

    23057/03 Dinchev, judgment of 22/01/2009, final on 22/04/2009

    75022/01 Popov Petyo, judgment of 22/01/2009, final on 22/04/2009

    - Case of length of civil proceedings and of lack of an effective remedy
    19207/04 Ivanov Petko, judgment of 26/03/2009, final on 26/06/2009

    - Cases of length of criminal proceedings and of lack of an effective remedy
    76942/01 Ivanov Valentin, judgment of 09/10/2008, final on 09/01/2009
    30380/03 Lisev, judgment of 26/02/2009, final on 26/05/2005
    43428/02 Myashev, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009
    72636/01 Valkov, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009
    76942/01 Ivanov Valentin, judgment of 26/03/2009, final on 26/06/2009

    - 6 cases against Croatia

    46598/06 Tomašić Branko and others, judgment of 15/01/2009, final on 15/04/2009

    38478/05 Janković, judgment of 05/03/2009, final on 05/06/2009

    9702/04 Gabrić, judgment of 05/02/2009, final on 05/05/2009

    25803/05 Siničić, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009

    22330/05 Olujić, judgment of 05/02/2009, final on 05/05/2009

    - Case of length of enforcement proceedings
    49916/07 Medić, judgment of 26/03/2009, final on 26/06/2009

    - 2 cases against Cyprus

    31811/04 Michael Theodossiou LtD, judgment of 15/01/2009, final on 15/04/2009

    37885/04 Charalambides, judgment of 15/01/2009, final on 15/04/2009

    - 1 case against the Czech Republic

    39298/04+ Krejčíř, judgment of 26/03/2009, final on 26/06/2009

    - 3 cases against Denmark

    26461/06 Valentin, judgment of 26/03/2009, final on 26/06/2009

    247/07 Christensen, judgment of 22/01/2009, final on 22/04/2009

    - Case of length of criminal proceedings
    36244/06 Hasslund, judgment of 11/12/2008, final on 11/03/2009

    - 1 case against Estonia

    - Case of length of civil proceedings and lack of an effective remedy
    43276/06 Missenjov, judgment of 29/01/2009, final on 29/04/2009

    - 7 cases against Finland

    - Case mainly concerning the search and seizure of privileged material
    19348/04 Sorvisto, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009

      - Case concerning the lack of a fair trial due to the fact that the applicant had not been given the opportunity to put questions to a prosecution witness, who was minor

    23220/04 A.L., judgment of 27/01/2009, final on 27/04/2009

      - Case concerning the unfairness of insurance proceedings due to impossibility of commenting on medical opinions included in the case file

    22635/04 Vilén, judgment of 17/02/2009, final on 17/05/2009

    - Cases of length of judicial proceedings
    33173/05 G., judgment of 27/01/2009, final on 27/04/2009
    39105/05 Jaanti, judgment of 24/02/2009, final on 24/05/2009
    47628/06 Kukkonen No. 2, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
    36989/05 Vienonen and others, judgment of 24/03/2009, final on 24/06/2009

    - 5 cases against France

    19421/04 Faure, judgment of 15/01/2009, final on 15/04/2009

    36497/05+ Ligue du monde islamique and Organisation islamique mondiale du secours, judgment of 15/01/2009, final on 15/04/2009

    24488/04 Guillard, judgment of 15/01/2009, final on 15/04/2009

    20985/05 Orban and others, judgment of 15/01/2009, final on 15/04/2009

    28336/02 Grifthorst, judgment of 26/02/2009, final on 26/05/2005

    - 7 cases against Georgia

    23204/07 Ghavtadze, judgment of 03/03/2009, final on 03/06/2009

    1704/06 Ramishvili and Kokhreidze, judgment of 27/01/2009, final on 27/04/2009

    522/04 Aliev, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009

    9870/07 Poghossian, judgment of 24/02/2009, final on 24/05/2009

    37048/04 Nikolaishvili Giorgi, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009

    7932/03 Jgarkava, judgment of 24/02/2009, final on 24/05/2009

    41957/04 Kharitonashvili, judgment of 10/02/2009, final on 10/05/2005

    - 3 cases against Germany

    - Cases of length of civil proceedings
    7634/05 Bozlar, judgment of 05/03/2009, final on 05/06/2009
    7369/04 Deiwick, judgment of 26/03/2009, final on 26/06/2009

    - Case of length of criminal proceedings
    45749/06+ Kaemena and Thöneböhn, judgment of 22/01/2009, final on 22/04/2009

    - 9 cases against Greece

    1234/05 Reklos and Davourlis, judgment of 15/01/2009, final on 15/04/2009

    42778/05+ Giosakis No 1, judgment of 12/02/2009, final on 12/05/2009
    36205/06 Giosakis No 2, judgment of 12/02/2009, final on 12/05/2009

      - Case mainly concerning the violation of the right to peaceful enjoyment of possessions due to failure to compensate for the progressive ban on construction affecting the property

    9368/06 Theodoraki and others, judgment of 11/12/2008, final on 04/05/2009

      - Cases mainly concerning the length of judicial proceedings and the lack of an effective remedy

    - Cases before administrative authorities and courts
    10468/04 Argyrou and others, judgment of 15/01/2009, final on 15/04/2009
    24454/07 Bekas, judgment of 12/03/2009, final on 12/06/2009
    21091/07 Michaïlidou and others, judgment of 12/03/2009, final on 12/06/2009
    26907/07 Nikitaki and others, judgment of 12/03/2009, final on 12/06/2009
    - Case before criminal courts
    23163/07 Sarantidis, judgment of 05/02/2009, final on 05/05/2005

    - 8 cases against Hungary

    12188/06 Csánics, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 29/04/2009

      - Cases of length of proceedings concerning civil rights and obligations and of lack of an effective remedy

    32069/05 Eösöly, judgment of 24/02/2009, final on 24/05/2009
    30799/04 Fonyódi, judgment of 07/10/2008, revised on 07/04/2009, final on 05/05/2009
    20075/05 Katona, judgment of 24/03/2009, final on 24/06/2009
    42260/05 Kustár, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009
    41453/05 Pátková, judgment of 24/03/2009, final on 24/06/2009

    - Cases of length of criminal proceedings
    15482/05 Aupek, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009
    16054/06 Borsódy and others, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 20/04/2009

    - 27 cases against Italy

    2638/07 Abdelhedi, judgment of 24/03/2009, final on 24/06/2009
    38128/06 Ben Salah, judgment of 24/03/2009, final on 24/06/2009
    46792/06 Bouyahia, judgment of 24/03/2009, final on 24/06/2009
    44006/06 C.B.Z., judgment of 24/03/2009, final on 24/06/2009
    246/07 Ben Khemais, judgment of 24/02/2009, final on 24/05/2009
    11549/05 Darraji, judgment of 24/03/2009, final on 24/06/2009
    16201/07 Hamraoui, judgment of 24/03/2009, final on 24/06/2009
    37257/06 O., judgment of 24/03/2009, final on 24/06/2009
    37336/06 Soltana, judgment of 24/03/2009, final on 24/06/2009

    33932/06 Todorova, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009

    29768/05 Errico, judgment of 24/02/2009, final on 24/05/2009

    75909/01 Sud Fondi Srl and others, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 20/04/2009

    46967/07 C.G.I.L. and Cofferati, judgment of 24/02/2009, final on 24/05/2009

    - Case concerning constructive expropriation
    16508/05 Sotira, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009

      - Cases mainly concerning unfair proceedings due to retrospective legislation reducing compensation for expropriation and insufficient compensation in this respect

    71399/01 Bortesi and others, judgment of 10/06/2008, final on 10/09/2008
    15581/05 Pierotti, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 20/04/2009

      - Case concerning bankruptcy proceedings (Articles 1 of Protocol No. 1 and 6§1)

    981/04 Shaw, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009

    - Cases concerning bankruptcy proceedings (Articles 8 and 13)
    26735/05 Cifra, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009
    33226/05 D’Apolito, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009
    40807/05 Fabiano, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009
    40824/05 Furno, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009
    11000/05 Massimo Maria Assunta, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009
    40261/05 Moroni, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009
    8681/05 Pedicini Umberto and Pedicini Pierpaolo, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009
    38264/05 Puzella and Cosentino, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009
    40664/05 Valentini, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009

      - Case concerning the effectiveness of the compensatory remedy (Pinto Act)

    - Case before civil courts
    680/03 Serino Luigi No. 2, judgment of 27/01/2009, final on 27/04/2009

    - 2 cases against Lithuania

    - Case of length of criminal proceedings
    302/05 Norkūnas, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 20/04/2009

    - Case of length of civil proceedings
    16013/02 Četvertakas and others, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 20/04/2009

    - 1 case against Luxembourg

    - Case of length of civil proceedings
    40761/05 Bodeving, judgment of 23/10/2008, final on 06/04/2009

    - 2 cases against Moldova

      - Cases concerning the failure or substantial delay by the administration in abiding by final domestic judgments

    37763/04+ Cebotari and others, judgment of 27/01/2009, final on 27/04/2009
    7365/05 Decev, judgment of 24/02/2009, final on 24/05/2009

    - Case concerning the quashing of final domestic judgments
    75/07 Duca, judgment of 03/03/2009, final on 03/06/2009

    - 33 cases against Poland

    11818/02 Mojsiejew, judgment of 24/03/2009, final on 24/06/2009

      - Cases concerning ill-treatment inflicted by the police and the lack of an effective remedy

    15562/02 Lewandowski and Lewandowska, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
    19616/04 Pieniak, judgment of 24/02/2009, final on 24/05/2009

    44369/02 Wenerski, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 20/04/2009

    23052/05 Kaprykowski, judgment of 03/02/2009, final on 03/05/2009

      - Case concerning the violation of the right for private and family life because of the refusal to allow a prisoner to attend his parents' funerals

    28586/03 Czarnowski, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 20/04/2009

      - Case concerning the lack of access to a court to challenge refusals to grant legal aid

    13526/07 Orzechowski Mirosłav, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009

    - Case concerning the lack of access to court on account of excessive court fees
    20482/03 Cibicki, judgment of 03/03/2009, final on 03/06/2009

    - Case concerning the unfairness of lustration proceedings
    34030/07 Jałowiecki, judgment of 17/02/2009, final on 17/05/2009

    - Cases concerning freedom of expression
    23806/03 Długołęcki, judgment of 24/02/2009, final on 24/05/2009
    53025/99 Frankowicz, judgment of 16/12/2008, final on 04/05/2009

    - Cases mainly concerning the length of detention on remand
    39163/06 Fiłon, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
    39469/02 Guziuk, judgment of 21/10/2008, final on 06/04/2009
    37976/06 Hilgartner, judgment of 03/03/2009, final on 03/06/2009
    22930/05 Kachel, judgment of 23/09/2008, final on 06/04/2009
    11825/07 Lemejda, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
    24023/06 Łoś, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
    3252/04 Pakos, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 20/04/2009
    52479/99 Rybacki, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
    37274/06 Sandowycz, judgment of 27/01/2009, final on 27/04/2009
    27992/06 Żywicki, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 20/04/2009

      - Case concerning the violation of the right to the presumption of innocence on account of the grounds used to prolong the applicant’s detention on remand

    4317/04 Kaźmierczack, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009

      - Cases concerning the length of proceedings before civil and labour courts and the lack of an effective remedy

    8934/05 Jagiełło No. 2, judgment of 02/12/2008, final on 06/04/2009, rectified on 05/02/2009
    46601/06 Kozłowski Romuald, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 20/04/2009
    45097/05 Kubik Arkadiusz, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
    17904/04 Nowak Dorota and Zbigniew, judgment of 24/03/2009, final on 24/06/2009
    7743/06 Sokołowska, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
    18414/03 Wolnicka, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009
    41701/07 Załuska, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009

      - Cases mainly concerning the length of criminal proceedings and the lack of an effective remedy

    39712/05 Dudek Janusz, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
    45219/06 Kauczor, judgment of 03/02/2009, final on 03/05/2009

    - Cases of length of proceedings concerning civil rights and obligations before administrative bodies and courts
    11522/03 Kliber, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
    23668/03 Wysocka and others, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009

    - 6 cases against Portugal

    31276/05 Women On Waves and others, judgment of 03/02/2009, final on 03/05/2009

      - Cases concerning inadequate compensation for land expropriated under the agrarian reform of 1975

    30844/05 De Avellar Cordeiro Zagallo, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
    31720/05 Kindler de Barahona, judgment of 10/02/2009, final on 10/05/2005
    44386/05 Melo e Faro Maldonado Passanha and others, judgment of 24/02/2009, final on 24/05/2009
    35254/05 Simões Alves Noronha, judgment of 03/03/2009, final on 03/06/2009
    30808/05 Vasconcelos Do Couto and 23 other “Agrarian reform” cases, judgment of 03/03/2009, final on 03/06/2009

    - 43 cases against Romania

    63258/00 Gagiu, judgment of 24/02/2009, final on 24/05/2009

    5325/03 Voiculescu, judgment of 03/02/2009, final on 03/05/2009

    42716/02 Toma, judgment of 24/02/2009, final on 24/05/2009

    22383/03 L.Z., judgment of 03/02/2009, final on 03/05/2009

    3584/02 Tarău, judgment of 24/02/2009, final on 24/05/2009

    4411/04 Băcanu and SC “R” SA, judgment of 03/03/2009, final on 03/06/2009

      - Case concerning the unfairness of civil proceedings on account of conflicting decisions by the Supreme Court in similar cases

    24428/03+ Ştefan and Ştef, judgment of 27/01/2009, final on 27/04/2009

    21911/03 Tudor Tudor, judgment of 24/03/2009, final on 24/06/2009

      - Case concerning the violation of the right of access to a court due to excessive court fees required

    38151/05 Rusen, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009

      - Case concerning the absence of an oral hearing on appeal in criminal proceedings

    30699/02 Marin, judgment of 03/02/2009, final on 03/05/2009

    26985/03 Burghelea, judgment of 27/01/2009, final on 27/04/2009

    - Cases concerning the annulment of final court decisions relating to property ownership
    3320/05 Petrini, judgment of 24/02/2009, final on 24/05/2009
    10230/05 Sersescu, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009

    - Cases concerning the annulment of final court decisions
    2367/04 Georgescu Daniel and Niculina, judgment of 27/01/2009, final on 27/04/2009
    17771/03 Precup, judgment of 27/01/2009, final on 27/04/2009

    23066/02 Faimblat, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009

      - Cases mainly concerning the failure to enforce final judicial decisions ordering the restitution of property nationalised or lost during the communist period

    28584/04 Constantinescu Elena and others, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009
    35823/03 Dimitru and Dumitrache, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 20/04/2009
    16707/03 Găină, judgment of 24/02/2009, final on 24/05/2009
    36478/02 Jones, judgment of 03/02/2009, final on 03/05/2009
    26094/03 Maeinescu and Mangu, judgment of 24/03/2009, final on 24/06/2009
    31153/03 Nicolescu, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 20/04/2009
    30043/04 Popovici Laurenciu, judgment of 24/02/2009, final on 24/05/2009

    25862/03 Deneş and others, judgment of 03/03/2009, final on 03/06/2009

    29739/03 Katz, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 20/04/2009, rectified on 05/05/2009

      - Cases concerning the failure to restore or compensate for nationalised property sold by the state to third parties

    8780/04 Călinescu, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009
    28607/04 Cernescu and Manolache, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009
    25234/03 Dumbravă, judgment of 17/02/2009, final on 17/05/2009
    16890/04 Gherase, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009
    10788/06 Ionescu and Istrate, judgment of 27/01/2009, final on 27/04/2009
    36128/04 Ionescu and Maftei, judgment of 27/01/2009, final on 27/04/2009
    17955/05 Marinescu, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
    41819/05 Paşcanu, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009
    3530/03 Stanciu, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009

    - Cases concerning failure by domestic authorities to assist in enforcing final judicial decisions placing obligations on private third parties
    37411/02 Abramiuc, judgment of 24/02/2009, final on 24/05/2009

      - Case concerning late enforcement of, or failure to enforce final judicial decisions by public institutions

    26004/03 Nitescu, judgment of 24/03/2009, final on 24/06/2009

      - Case concerning the impossibility to obtain possession of a land or equivalent compensation, due to the existence of a second property title delivered to third persons under Law No. 18/1991

    252/04 Hîrgău and Arsinte, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 20/04/2009

    9164/02 Ichim, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009

    - Cases concerning unlawful submission of allowance to income tax
    23887/03 Bălăucă, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
    26852/03 Bizau, judgment of 27/01/2009, final on 27/04/2009
    8027/03 Bozian, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
    13480/03 Gavriş, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009
    26845/03 Gologus, judgment of 27/01/2009, final on 27/04/2009

    - 52 cases against the Russian Federation

    - Cases concerning security forces in the Chechen Republic
    27256/03 Astamirova and others, judgment of 26/02/2009, final on 26/05/2005
    27238/03 Dzhambekova and others, judgment of 12/03/2009, final on 12/06/2009
    21816/03 Elsiyev and others, judgment of 12/03/2009, final on 12/06/2009
    5351/04 Khadayeva and others, judgment of 12/03/2009, final on 12/06/2009
    21519/02 Khadisov and Tsechoyev, judgment of 05/02/2009, rectified on 04/05/2009, final on 05/05/2005
    39166/04 Khalitova, judgment of 05/03/2009, final on 05/06/2009
    4573/04 Sagayev and others, judgment of 26/02/2009, final on 26/05/2005
    1200/03 Umayeva, judgment of 04/12/2008, final on 04/05/2009
    21080/05 Vagapova and Zubirayev, judgment of 26/02/2009, rectified on 27/03/2009, final on 26/05/2005

      - Cases concerning unlawful detention, excessive length and insufficient grounds and length of criminal proceedings

    22674/02 Oblov, judgment of 15/01/2009, final on 15/04/2009
    13541/06 Shkilev, judgment of 19/03/2009, final on 19/06/2009
    36551/07 Yelizarov, judgment of 26/03/2009, final on 26/06/2009
    40258/03 Yudayev, judgment of 15/01/2009, final on 15/04/2009

      - Cases mainly concerning ill-treatment inflicted on the applicants while in custody and the lack of an effective investigation

    36220/02 Barabanshchikov, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009
    3811/02 Denisenko and Bogdanchikov, judgment of 12/02/2009, final on 12/05/2009
    30033/05 Polonskiy, judgment of 19/03/2009, final on 19/06/2009

      - Cases mainly concerning the applicants’ poor conditions of detention

    22107/03 Antropov, judgment of 29/01/2009, final on 29/04/2009
    28617/03 Belashev, judgment of 04/12/2008, final on 04/05/2009
    39420/03 Bychkov, judgment of 05/03/2009, final on 05/06/2009
    15217/07 Makarov Aleksandr, judgment of 12/03/2009, final on 12/06/2009
    6270/06 Lyubimenko, judgment of 19/03/2009, final on 19/06/2009
    6954/02 Maltabar and Maltabar, judgment of 29/01/2009, final on 29/04/2009
    11982/02 Novinskiy, judgment of 10/02/2009, final on 10/05/2005

    - Cases concerning extradition
    42443/02 Eminbeyli, judgment of 26/02/2009, final on 26/05/2005
    13476/04 Khudyakova, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009
    42502/06 Muminov, judgment of 11/12/2008, final on 04/05/2009

    32147/04 Kuimov, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009

    18274/04 Borzhonov, judgment of 22/01/2009, final on 22/04/2009

      - Cases concerning the domestic courts' refusal to examine defence witnesses in proceedings which resulted in the applicants’ conviction

    13769/04 Makeyev, judgment of 05/02/2009, final on 05/05/2005
    77018/01 Polyakov, judgment of 29/01/2009, final on 29/04/2009

      - Case concerning the violation of the right to a fair hearing before a “tribunal established by law”

    38697/02+ Laryagin and Aristov, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009

    3891/03 Samokhvalov, judgment of 12/02/2009, final on 12/05/2009

    42454/02 Menchinskaya, judgment of 15/01/2009, final on 15/04/2009

    - Cases concerning freedom of expression
    29492/05 Kudeshkina, judgment of 26/02/2009, final on 26/05/2005
    34736/03 Obukhova, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009

    33509/04 Burdov No. 2, judgment of 15/01/2009, final on 04/05/2009

      - Cases mainly concerning the failure or substantial delay by the administration or state companies in abiding by final domestic judgments

    32048/03 Bezzoubikova, judgment of 10/02/2009, final on 10/05/2005
    746/05+ Kazmina Nina and others, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
    2068/03+ Kondrashov and others, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009
    25114/03+ Kulkov and others, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009
    8363/03 Veretennikov, judgment of 12/03/2009, final on 12/06/2009
    5249/06 Zhuralev, judgment of 15/01/2009, final on 15/04/2009

      - Cases concerning the failure or substantial delay by the administration or state companies in abiding by final domestic judgments

    Housing disputes (former military)
    25971/03 Kotsar, judgment of 29/01/2009, final on 29/04/2009
    16048/06 Lotorevich, judgment of 22/01/2009, final on 22/04/2009

      - Cases concerning quashing of final judgments through the supervisory review procedure

    17472/04 Bodrov, judgment of 12/02/2009, final on 12/05/2009
    63997/00 Fedorov, judgment of 26/02/2009, final on 26/05/2005
    19136/04 Kalinichenko, judgment of 12/03/2009, final on 12/06/2009
    38103/04 Nikolenko, judgment of 26/03/2009, final on 26/06/2009
    8927/02 Sharomov, judgment of 15/01/2009, final on 15/04/2009
    51380/07 Zakharov, judgment of 12/03/2009, final on 12/06/2009

    - Cases of length of civil proceedings
    13119/03 Markova, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009
    16004/04 Rypakova, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009

    - 2 cases against Serbia

      - Case concerning the failure or substantial delay by the administration in abiding by final domestic judgments

    35835/05+ Crnišanin, Hamidović, Kostić and Paljevac, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009

    - Case of length of judicial proceedings and lack of an effective remedy
    Labour case
    33029/05 Dorić, judgment of 27/01/2009, final on 27/04/2009

    - 3 cases against the Slovak Republic

    67149/01 Berková, judgment of 24/03/2009, final on 24/06/2009

    - Cases of length of proceedings concerning civil rights and obligations
    15592/03 Dudičová, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009
    30036/06 Martikán, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 20/04/2009

    - 2 cases against Slovenia

    37496/04 Iguall Coll, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009

    - Case of length of proceedings concerning civil rights and obligations
    21415/02 Rogelj, judgment of 03/03/2009, final on 03/06/2009

    - 2 cases against Spain

    36777/03 Iribarren Pinillos, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009

    - Case concerning the right of access to a court
    1518/04 Golf de Extremadura S.A., judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009

    - 1 case against “the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia"

    74651/01 Association of citizens “Radko” and Paunkovski, judgment of 15/01/2009, final on 15/04/2009

    - 63 cases against Turkey

    70337/07 Güveç, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 20/04/2009

    7496/03 Uyan Filiz, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009

    - Cases concerning the actions of the Turkish security forces
    a) Cases concerning the failure to protect the right to life and / or the lack of effective investigation into the death of the applicants’ relatives
    30304/02 Akın Halis, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
    33750/03 Yeter, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
    b) Cases concerning the inhuman and degrading treatment of the applicants and/or the absence of effective investigations
    71912/01 Böke and Kandemir, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009
    39324/02 Çelik No. 1, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 20/04/2009
    25172/02 Çamçi and others, judgment of 24/02/2009, final on 24/05/2009
    15828/03 Salmanoğlu and Polattaş, judgment of 17/03/2009, final on 17/06/2009

      - Case concerning the failure to protect the right to life during military service and/or the lack of an effective investigation in this respect

    27866/03 Beker, judgment of 24/03/2009, final on 24/06/2009

      - Cases mainly concerning the excessive use of force to break up unlawful but peaceful demonstrations

    31451/03 Açık and others, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
    16999/04 Karabulut Samüt, judgment of 27/01/2009, final on 27/04/2009

    - Cases mainly concerning freedom of expression
    27690/03 Güçlü, judgment of 10/02/2009, final on 10/05/2005
    15719/03 İlhan Mehmet Cevher, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
    24748/03 İmza, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 20/04/2009

    - Case concerning freedom of expression – defamation proceedings
    39656/03 Erdoğan Ayhan, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009

    - Case concerning freedom of expression – broadcasting legislation
    10129/04 Özgür Radyo – Ses Radyo-Televizyon Yayın Yapım Ve Tanıtım A.Ş., judgment of 10/02/2009, final on 10/05/2005

    36458/02 Taşcıgil, judgment of 03/03/2009, final on 03/06/2009

    23815/04 Uslu No. 2, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 20/04/2009

      - Cases mainly concerning the failure to communicate the public prosecutor's opinion before the Court of Cassation and / or the lack of oral hearing in compensation proceedings

    19582/02 Çimen, judgment of 03/02/2009, final on 03/05/2009
    17149/03 Duman, judgment of 27/01/2009, final on 27/04/2009

      - Cases mainly concerning the unfairness of criminal proceedings due to the lack of the assistance of counsel during detention in custody

    7638/02 Aba, judgment of 03/03/2009, final on 03/06/2009
    5138/04 Amutgan, judgment of 03/02/2009, final on 03/05/2009
    38940/02+ Aslan and Demir, judgment of 17/02/2009, final on 17/05/2009
    6058/02 Ek and Şıktaş, judgment of 17/02/2009, final on 17/05/2009
    24468/03 Gülbahar and Tut, judgment of 24/02/2009, final on 24/05/2009
    16500/04 Öztürk İbrahim, judgment of 17/02/2009, final on 17/05/2009
    16943/03 Taşcıgil, judgment of 03/03/2009, final on 03/06/2009

      - Case concerning the annulment of titles of property belonging to minority religious foundations, more than thirty years after lawful acquisition

    37639/03+ Bozcaada Kimisis Teodoku Rum Ortodoks Kilisesi Vakfı No. 2, judgment of 03/03/2009, final on 03/06/2009

      - Case concerning the lack of compensation for the loss of title to property under Article 38 of Law on Expropriation

    29188/02 Erbey, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009

      - Cases concerning the lack of compensation for the loss of title to property on account of their designation as public forest

    17203/03 Devecioğlu, judgment of 13/11/2008, final on 04/05/2009
    18257/04 Rimer and others, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009
    36192/03 Şatır, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009
    45651/04 Temel Conta Sanayi ve Ticaret A.Ş., judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009
    16009/04 Vural Nural, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009

      - Cases concerning the failure or substantial delay by the administration in abiding by final domestic judgments

    42894/04+ Arat and others, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
    11098/04 Sarıkaya Yavuz, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
    6124/02 Şahin mehmet Emin, judgment of 24/03/2009, final on 24/06/2009

      - Cases concerning delays by the administration in paying additional compensation for expropriation and the applicable rate of default interest

    27045/02 Argunhan, judgment of 03/03/2009, final on 03/06/2009
    22261/03 Durmaz M. Ali, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009
    473/03 Gür and Yıldız, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
    19255/02 Işik, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009
    36424/06 Kılıç Kemal, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009

    4661/02 Şükran and others, judgment of 03/02/2009, final on 03/05/2009

    18992/03 Elğay, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 20/04/2009

      - Cases mainly concerning the length of detention on remand and/or of criminal proceedings

    35561/06 Akpolat, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009
    42296/07 Çelik Mehmet Ali, judgment of 27/01/2009, final on 27/04/2009
    7263/04 Kesikkulak, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009
    33631/04 Yaman Mahmut, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 20/04/2009

    - Cases concerning detention in custody
    7306/02 Baizi, judgment of 17/02/2009, final on 17/05/2009
    17019/02+ İpek and others, judgment of 03/02/2009, final on 03/05/2009

    - Cases mainly concerning the length of judicial proceedings and the lack of an effective remedy
    - Cases before administrative courts
    9574/03 Akan, judgment of 17/02/2009, final on 17/05/2009
    1895/05 Aras, judgment of 17/02/2009, final on 17/05/2009
    25580/03 Hasefe, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009
    17533/04 Özoğuz, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 20/04/2009
    - Cases before criminal courts
    23085/04 Korkmaz Yalçın, judgment of 25/11/2008, final on 25/02/2009
    36526/04 Özcan, judgment of 03/02/2009, final on 03/05/2009
    - Cases before civil courts
    61/04 Çayğan, judgment of 27/01/2009, final on 27/04/2009
    9437/04 Karaduman Hamiye and others, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 20/04/2009
    42710/04 Saçlı and others, judgment of 03/02/2009, final on 03/05/2009
    - Cases before cadastre courts
    1533/03 Şerefli and others, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 20/04/2009
    8782/02 Uğur Ali Kemal and others, judgment of 03/03/2009, final on 03/06/2009
    - Case before commercial courts
    28388/03 Güngil, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009

    - Case of length of criminal proceedings before state security courts
    34740/03 Bozlak and others, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009

    - 24 cases against Ukraine

    1291/03 Volosyuk Sergey, judgment of 12/03/2009, final on 12/06/2009

    - Case concerning extradition
    2929/05 Svetlorusov, judgment of 12/03/2009, final on 12/03/2009

      - Case mainly concerning inhuman and/or degrading treatment in detention resulting from overcrowding, unsatisfactory hygiene and sanitation conditions or inadequate medical care, as well as lack of an effective remedy

    18660/03 Malenko, judgment of 19/02/2009, final on 19/05/2009

    - Cases mainly concerning ill treatment inflicted on the applicant while in custody
    39188/04 Suptel, judgment of 19/02/2009, final on 19/05/2009
    19312/06 Vergelskyy, judgment of 12/03/2009, final on 12/03/2009

      - Cases concerning unlawful detention, excessive length and insufficient grounds as well as inhuman and/or degrading treatment in detention

    16505/02 Doronin, judgment of 19/02/2009, final on 19/05/2009
    16447/04 Kucherenko Nikolay, judgment of 19/02/2009, final on 19/05/2009
    34211/04 Miroshnichenko Roman, judgment of 19/02/2009, final on 19/05/2009

    16404/03 Shabelnik, judgment of 19/02/2009, final on 19/05/2009

    20347/03 Plakhteyev and Plakhteyeva, judgment of 12/03/2009, final on 12/03/2009

    - Case concerning freedom of expression
    4063/04 Marchenko, judgment of 19/02/2009, final on 19/05/2009

      - Cases mainly concerning the failure or substantial delay by the administration or state companies in abiding by final domestic judgments

    18024/04 Andriychuk, judgment of 19/02/2009, final on 19/05/2009
    12380/05 Bondar and others, judgment of 19/02/2009, final on 19/05/2009
    20728/04 Kooperativ Kakhovskiy-5, judgment of 19/02/2009, final on 19/05/2009
    36772/04 Krasovskiy, judgment of 12/03/2009, final on 12/03/2009
    1811/06 Kryshchuk, judgment of 19/02/2009, final on 19/05/2009
    37208/04 Lebedintseva, judgment of 12/03/2009, final on 12/03/2009
    38683/04 Matkivska, judgment of 12/03/2009, final on 12/03/2009
    1755/05+ Otychenko and Fedishchenko, judgment of 12/03/2009, final on 12/03/2009
    39876/05+ Vasylyeva and others, judgment of 12/03/2009, final on 12/03/2009
    39874/05 Voskoboynyk, judgment of 12/03/2009, final on 12/03/2009

    - Cases of length of civil proceedings
    1866/04 Buryak, judgment of 19/02/2009, final on 19/05/2009
    21263/04 Voishchev, judgment of 19/02/2009, final on 19/05/2009
    41286/04 Voronenkov, judgment of 19/02/2009, final on 19/05/2009

    - 7 cases against the United Kingdom

      - Cases concerning discrimination between widows and widowers on grounds of gender regarding social security benefits

    27961/02 Booth, judgment of 03/02/2009, final on 03/05/2009
    42711/02 Mitchard, judgment of 03/02/2009, final on 03/05/2009
    28045/02 Murray, judgment of 03/02/2009, final on 03/05/2009
    28091/02 Thorne, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
    42709/02 Turner, judgment of 03/02/2009, final on 03/05/2009
    28095/02 Twomey, judgment of 03/02/2009, final on 03/05/2009

    - Case of length of criminal proceedings
    3383/06 Bullen and Soneji, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009, rectified on 27/01/2009

    SECTION 3 - JUST SATISFACTION

    Action

    The Deputies are invited to supervise the payment of just satisfaction in the following cases pending before the Committee of Ministers for execution supervision. The Deputies are invited to resume consideration of these cases in principle at their next Human Rights meeting.

    Supervision of payment is dealt with through separate tables distributed each month. An updated version will be distributed just before each meeting.

    The Deputies decided to resume consideration of these items at their 1072nd meeting (1-3 and 4 (morning) December 2009) (DH), in the light of information to be provided on the payment of the just satisfaction, if necessary.

    SECTION 4 - CASES RAISING SPECIFIC QUESTIONS
    (INDIVIDUAL MEASURES, MEASURES NOT YET DEFINED OR SPECIAL PROBLEMS)

    (See Addendum 4 for part or all these cases)

    Action

    The Deputies are invited to supervise the progress made in the adoption of the implementing measures in the following cases raising several problems. Supplementary information on some or all the cases listed below may be issued in Addendum 4. The Deputies are invited to resume consideration of these items on a case-by-case basis

    SUB-SECTION 4.1 – SUPERVISION OF INDIVIDUAL MEASURES ONLY2

    - 1 case against Austria

    36812/97+ Sylvester, judgment of 24/04/03, final on 24/07/03

    - 1 case against Azerbaijan

    5548/03 Hajiyev, judgment of 16/11/2006, final on 16/02/2007

    - 7 cases against Croatia

    - Cases of length of civil proceedings
    29159/03 Poje, judgment of 09/03/2006, final on 09/06/2006
    32264/03 Butković, judgment of 24/05/2007, final on 24/08/2007, rectified on 05/09/2007
    8854/04 Krnić, judgment of 31/07/2008, final on 01/12/2008
    26455/04 Plazonić, judgment of 06/03/2008, final on 06/06/2008
    21591/06 Pleteš, judgment of 10/07/2008, final on 29/09/2008
    43709/02 Raguž, judgment of 10/11/2005, final on 10/02/2006
    5129/03 Sukobljević, judgment of 02/11/2006, final on 02/02/2007

    - 1 case against Poland

    42049/98 Związek Nauczycielstwa Polskiego, judgment of 21/10/2004, final on 02/02/2005

    - 2 cases against the Slovak Republic

    17684/02 Rosival and others, judgment of 23/09/2008 – Friendly settlement

    57239/00 Kanala, judgment of 10/07/2007, final on 30/01/2008 and of 14/10/2008, final on 06/04/2009

    - 1 case against Turkey

    36391/02 Salduz, judgment of 27/11/2008 – Grand Chamber

    SUB-SECTION 4.2 – INDIVIDUAL MEASURES AND/OR GENERAL PROBLEMS

    - 1 case against Albania

    37959/02 Xheraj, judgment of 29/07/2008, final on 01/12/2008

    - 1 case against Armenia

    21638/03 Paykar Yev Haghtanak Ltd, judgment of 20/12/2007, final on 02/06/2008

    - 12 cases against Austria

      - Cases of length of proceedings concerning civil rights and obligations before administrative authorities and courts

    2884/04 Ortner, judgment of 31/05/2007, final on 31/08/2007
    38032/05 Gierlinger, judgment of 29/11/2007, final on 29/02/2008
    37040/02 Riepl, judgment of 03/02/2005, final on 03/05/2005

      - Cases of length of judicial proceedings concerning the determination of criminal charges before administrative authorities and courts and of lack of an effective remedy

    56483/00 Jancikova, judgment of 07/04/2005, final on 07/07/2005
    32407/04 Donner, judgment of 22/02/2007, final on 22/05/2007
    20597/04 Gürsoy, judgment of 05/06/2008, final on 05/09/2008
    37301/03 Hauser-Sporn, judgment of 07/12/2006, final on 23/05/2007
    28034/04 Müller No. 2, judgment of 18/09/2008, final on 18/12/2008
    25166/05 Schneider, judgment of 31/07/2008, final on 31/10/2008
    18015/03 Schütte, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007
    18294/03 Stempfer, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007
    8140/04 Vitzthum, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007

    - 2 cases against Azerbaijan

    16528/05 Hajibeyli, judgment of 10/07/2008, final on 10/10/2008

    34640/02 Rahmanova, judgment of 10/07/2008, final on 10/10/2008

    - 2 cases against Belgium

    20656/03 Loncke, judgment of 25/09/2007, final on 25/12/2007

    58081/00+ Leschiutta and Fraccaro, judgment of 17/07/2008, final on 17/10/2008

    - 1 case against Bosnia and Herzegovina

    22893/05 Rodić and 3 others, judgment of 27/05/2008, final on 01/12/2008

    - 12 cases against Bulgaria

    52435/99 Ivanova, judgment of 12/04/2007, final on 12/07/2007

    15197/02 Petrov, judgment of 22/05/2008, final on 22/08/2008

    44009/02 Ivanov Evgeni, judgment of 22/05/2008, final on 22/08/2008
    15158/02 Kirilov, judgment of 22/05/2008, final on 22/08/2008

      - Cases concerning infringements of the freedom of assembly of organisations which aim to achieve “the recognition of the Macedonian minority in Bulgaria” and of their members

    44079/98 United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden and Ivanov, judgment of 20/10/2005, final on 15/02/2006
    46336/99 Ivanov and others, judgment of 24/11/2005, final on 24/02/2006

      - Cases mainly concerning the interception of the applicant's telephone conversations

    62540/00 Association for European Integration and Human Rights and Ekimdzhiev, judgment of 28/06/2007, final on 30/01/2008
    5182/02 Kirov, judgment of 22/05/2008, final on 22/08/2008

    50899/99 Yordanov Krasimir, judgment of 15/02/2007, final on 15/05/2007

9808/02 Stoichkov, judgment of 24/03/2005, final on 24/06/2005

    66455/01 Bulinwar OOD and Hrusanov, judgment of 12/04/2007, final on 12/07/2007

    17868/07 Mihaylov Kostadin, judgment of 27/03/2008, final on 27/06/2008

    - 2 cases against Croatia

    11223/04 X., judgment of 17/07/2008, final on 01/12/2008

    43595/06 Bačić, judgment of 19/06/2008, final on 01/12/2008

    - 6 cases against Finland

    40199/02 Kallio, judgment of 22/07/2008, final on 22/10/2008
    32993/02 Lehtinen Hannu, judgment of 22/07/2008, final on 22/10/2008

    50882/99 Sallinen Petri and others, judgment of 27/09/2005, final on 27/12/2005

    10163/02 Johansson, judgment of 06/09/2007, final on 06/12/2007

    40412/98 V., judgment of 24/04/2007, final on 24/07/2007

    68050/01 Ekholm, judgment of 24/07/2007, final on 24/10/2007

    - 3 cases against France

    9375/02 Saoud, judgment of 09/10/2007, final on 09/01/2008

    34043/02 Mattei, judgment of 19/12/2006, final on 19/03/2007
    73529/01 Miraux, judgment of 26/09/2006, final on 12/02/2007

    - 5 cases against Georgia

    9103/04 The Georgian Labour Party, judgment of 08/07/2008, final on 08/10/2008

    18145/05 Gigolashvili, judgment of 08/07/2008, final on 08/10/2008

    30779/04 Patsuria, judgment of 06/11/2007, final on 06/02/2008

    40765/02 Apostol, judgment of 28/11/2006, final on 28/02/2007

    69852/01 Kidzinidzé, judgment of 29/01/2008, final on 07/07/2008

    - 1 case against Greece

    44858/04 Markoulaki No. 1, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007

    - 2 cases against Hungary

    44378/05 Daróczy, judgment of 01/07/2008, final on 01/10/2008

    33629/06 Vajnai, judgment of 08/07/2008, final on 08/10/2008

    - 4 cases against Latvia

    62393/00 Kadiķis No. 2, judgment of 04/05/2006, final on 04/08/2006

    3669/03 Ādamsons, judgment of 24/06/2008, final on 01/12/2008

    73819/01 Estrikh, judgment of 18/01/2006, final on 18/04/2007
    67275/01 Čistiakov, judgment of 08/02/2007, final on 08/05/2007

    - 9 cases against Malta

    26111/02 Mizzi, judgment of 12/01/2006, final on 12/04/2006

    17209/02 Adami Zarb, judgment of 20/06/2006, final on 20/09/2006

    - Cases of length of civil proceedings
    34539/02 Debono, judgment of 07/02/2006, final on 07/05/2006
    15091/06 Bezzina Wettinger and others, judgment of 08/04/2008, final on 08/07/2008
    35829/03 Central Mediterranean Development Corporation Limited, judgment of 24/10/2006, final on 24/01/2007

    77562/01 San Leonard Band Club, judgment of 29/07/2004, final on 29/10/2004

    35349/05 Fleri Soler and Camilleri, judgment of 26/09/2006, final on 26/12/2006 and of 17/07/2008, final on 17/10/2008 (Article 41)
    31122/05 Ghigo, judgment of 26/09/2006, final on 26/12/2006 and of 17/07/2008, final on 17/10/2008 (Article 41)
    17647/04 Edwards; judgment of 24/10/2006, final on 24/01/2007 and of 17/07/2008, final on 06/04/2009 (Article 41)

    - 44 cases against Poland

    11562/05 Byrzykowski, judgment of 27/06/2006, final on 27/09/2006

    5410/03 Tysiąc, judgment of 20/03/2007, final on 24/09/2007

    54723/00 Brudnicka and others, judgment of 03/03/2005, final on 03/06/2005

    - Cases mainly concerning the monitoring of prisoners’ correspondence
    31583/96 Klamecki No. 2, judgment of 03/04/03, final on 03/07/03
    43120/05 Andrulewicz, judgment of 03/04/2007, final on 24/09/2007
    31038/06 Andrysiak, judgment of 20/05/2008, final on 20/08/2008
    20138/03 Bobel, judgment of 22/01/2008, final on 22/04/2008
    26846/05 Ćwiertniak, judgment of 22/07/2008, final on 22/10/2008
    20841/02 Drozdowski, judgment of 06/12/2005, final on 06/03/2006
    35833/03 Dzitkowski, judgment of 27/11/2007, final on 27/02/2008
    55470/00 Ferla, judgment of 20/05/2008, final on 20/08/2008
    36161/05 Jakubiak, judgment of 08/01/2008, final on 07/07/2008
    72976/01 Jasiński, judgment of 06/12/2007, final on 06/03/2008
    8363/04 Kliza, judgment of 06/09/2007, final on 06/12/2007
    44521/04 Kołodziński, judgment of 08/01/2008, final on 07/07/2008
    10816/02 Kozimor, judgment of 12/04/2007, final on 12/07/2007
    51895/99 Kwiek, judgment of 30/05/2006, final on 30/08/2006
    21890/03 Lewak, judgment of 06/09/2007, final on 31/03/2008
    73988/01 Łuczko, judgment of 03/10/2006, final on 03/01/2007
    14450/02 Maksym, judgment of 19/12/2006, final on 19/03/2007
    37641/97 Matwiejczuk, judgment of 02/12/03, final on 02/03/04
    42083/98 Mianowski, judgment of 16/12/03, final on 16/03/04
    43837/06 Misiak, judgment of 03/06/2008, final on 03/09/2008
    62323/00 Najdecki, judgment of 06/02/2007, final on 06/05/2007
    6390/03 Nowicki, judgment of 27/02/2007, final on 27/05/2007
    8260/04 Ochlik, judgment of 29/07/2008, final on 29/10/2008
    64284/01 Oleksy, judgment of 28/11/2006, final on 28/02/2007
    10381/04 Owsik, judgment of 16/10/2007, final on 16/01/2008
    24322/02 Panusz, judgment of 03/06/2008, final on 01/12/2008
    39840/05 Pawlak, judgment of 15/01/2008, final on 15/04/2008
    92/03 Pisk-Piskowski, judgment of 14/06/2005, final on 14/09/2005
    29366/03 Stępniak, judgment of 29/01/2008, final on 29/04/2008
    64283/01 Tomczyk Prokopyszyn, judgment of 28/03/2006, final on 28/06/2006
    38007/02 Warsiński, judgment of 04/12/2007, final on 04/03/2008
    63905/00 Wasilewski, judgment of 06/12/2005, final on 06/03/2006
    39519/05 Zborowski No. 3, judgment of 22/04/2008, final on 22/07/2008, rectified on 06/05/2008
    45133/06 Zborowski, judgment of 15/01/2008, final on 15/04/2008

    1543/06 Bączkowski and others, judgment of 03/05/2007, final on 24/09/2007

    - Cases concerning the unfairness of lustration proceedings
    38184/03 Matyjek, judgment of 24/04/2007, final on 24/09/2007
    68761/01 Bobek, judgment of 17/07/2007, final on 10/12/2007
    37469/05 Luboch, judgment of 15/01/2008, final on 15/04/2008

    22860/02 Woś, judgment of 08/06/2006, final on 08/09/2006

    59444/00 Kania, judgment of 10/05/2007, final on 10/08/2007
    23779/02 Kozłowski, judgment of 23/01/2007, final on 23/04/2007

    - 3 cases against Portugal

    20620/04 Azevedo, judgment of 27/03/2008, final on 27/06/2008

    17107/05 Campos Dâmaso, judgment of 24/04/2008, final on 24/07/2008

    73229/01 Reigado Ramos, judgment of 22/11/2005, final on 22/02/2006

    - 3 cases against Romania

    26105/03 Mitrea, judgment of 29/07/2008, final on 01/12/2008

    42250/02 Calmanovici, judgment of 01/07/2008, final on 01/10/2008, rectified on 10/02/2009

    1562/02 Gaga, judgment of 25/03/2008, final on 29/09/2008

    - 63 cases against the Russian Federation

      - Cases mainly concerning ill-treatment inflicted on the applicants while in custody and the lack of an effective investigation

    77617/01 Mikheyev, judgment of 26/01/2006, final on 26/04/2006
    5742/02 Akulinin and Babich, judgment of 02/10/2008, final on 02/01/2009
    839/02 Maslova and Nalbandov, judgment of 24/01/2008, final on 07/07/2008
    65859/01 Sheydayev, judgment of 07/12/2006, final on 23/05/2007
    78145/01 Kovalev, judgment of 10/05/2007, final on 12/11/2007

    7188/03 Chember, judgment of 03/07/2008, final on 01/12/2008

    - Cases concerning unlawful detention, excessive length and insufficient grounds
    CM/Inf/DH(2007)4
    46082/99 Klyakhin, judgment of 30/11/05, final on 06/06/05
    21153/02 Bednov, judgment of 01/06/2006, final on 01/09/2006
    72967/01 Belevitskiy, judgment of 01/03/2007, final on 01/06/2007
    22053/02 Belov, judgment of 03/07/2008, final on 03/10/2008
    11886/05 Dolgova, judgment of 02/03/2006, final on 03/07/2006
    31008/02 Fedorov and Fedorova, judgment of 13/10/2005, final on 13/01/2006
    26386/02 Fursenko, judgment of 24/04/2008, final on 24/07/2008
    16595/02 Golovkin, judgment of 03/04/2008, final on 29/09/2008
    42940/06 Govorushko, judgment of 25/10/2007, final on 25/01/2008
    67542/01 Gusev, judgment of 15/05/2008, final on 15/08/2008
    70276/01 Gusinskiy, judgment of 19/05/2004, final on 10/11/2004
    27193/02 Ignatov, judgment of 24/05/2007, final on 24/08/2007

    59696/00 Khudobin, judgment of 26/10/2006, final on 26/01/2007
    6847/02 Khudoyorov, judgment of 08/11/2005, final on 12/04/2006
    19126/02 Komarova, judgment of 02/11/2006, final on 02/02/2007
    75039/01 Korchuganova, judgment of 08/06/2006, final on 08/09/2006
    38971/06 Korshunov, judgment of 25/10/2007, final on 25/01/2008
    4493/04 Lebedev, judgment of 25/10/2007, final on 02/06/2008
    3223/07 Makarov Aleksey, judgment of 12/06/2008, final on 12/09/2008
    7064/05 Mamedova, judgment of 01/06/2006, final on 23/10/2006
    18123/04 Matskus, judgment of 21/02/2008, final on 21/05/2008
    24552/02 Melnikova, judgment of 21/06/2007, final on 30/01/2008
    36911/02 Mishketkul and others, judgment of 24/05/2007, final on 12/11/2007
    55669/00 Nakhmanovitch, arrêt du 02/03/2006, final on 02/06/2006
    45100/98 Panchenko, judgment of 08/02/2005, final on 08/05/2005
    32327/06 Popkov, judgment of 15/05/2008, final on 29/09/2008
    28957/02 Pshevecherskiy, judgment of 24/05/2007, final on 24/08/2007
    54071/00 Rokhlina, judgment of 07/04/2005, final on 12/10/2005
    64140/00 Rozhkov, judgment of 19/07/2007, final on 12/11/2007
    7649/02 Shcheglyuk, judgment of 14/12/2006, final on 14/03/2007
    65734/01 Shukhardin, judgment of 28/06/2007, final on 28/09/2007
    4459/03 Sidorenko, judgment of 08/03/2007, final on 08/06/2007
    3947/03 Silin, judgment of 24/04/2008, final on 24/07/2008
    46133/99+ Smirnova, judgment of 24/07/2003, final on 24/10/2003
    2708/02 Solovyev Vladimir, judgment of 24/05/2007, final on 12/11/2007
    942/02 Zementova, judgment of 27/09/2007, final on 27/12/2007

    7178/03 Dedovskiy and others, judgment of 15/05/2008, final on 15/08/2008

    44009/05 Shtukaturov, judgment of 27/03/2008, final on 27/06/2008

    1509/02 Tatishvili, judgment of 22/02/2007, final on 09/07/2007

    15339/02+ Budayeva and others, judgment of 20/03/2008, final on 29/09/2008

    71362/01 Smirnov, judgment of 07/06/2007, final on 12/11/2007

    14810/02 Ryakib Biryukov, judgment of 17/01/2008, final on 07/07/2008

      - Cases mainly concerning quashing of final judgments on the basis of newly discovered circumstances

    69529/01 Pravednaya, judgment of 18/11/2004, final on 30/03/2005
    69524/01 Bulgakova, judgment of 18/01/2007, final on 18/04/2007 and of 10/06/2008 – Friendly settlement
    69533/01 Kondrashina, judgment of 19/07/2007, final on 30/01/2008
    73294/01 Kumkin and others, judgment of 05/07/2007, final on 30/01/2008
    67579/01 Kuznetsova, judgment of 07/06/2007, final on 12/11/2007
    944/02 Levochkina, judgment of 05/07/2007, final on 31/03/2008
    76676/01 Maltseva, judgment of 19/06/2008, final on 19/09/2008
    852/02 Smirnitskaya and others, judgment of 05/07/2007, final on 31/03/2008
    11589/04 Tetsen, judgment of 03/04/2008, final on 03/07/2008
    25580/02 Vedernikova, judgment of 12/07/2007, final on 31/03/2008
    842/02 Volkova and Basova, judgment of 05/07/2007, final on 31/03/2008
    77478/01 Yerogova, judgment of 19/06/2008, final on 19/09/2008
    560/02 Zhukov Nikolay, judgment of 05/07/2007, final on 31/03/2008

    73043/01 Arshinchikova, judgment of 29/03/2007, final on 29/06/2007

    65582/01 Radchikov, judgment of 24/05/2007, final on 12/11/2007

    - 1 case against Slovenia

    43393/98 Matko, judgment of 02/11/2006, final on 02/02/2007

    - 27 cases against “the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia"

      - Cases concerning lack of effective investigation of allegations of ill-treatment by the police

    69908/01 Jasar, judgment of 15/02/2007, final on 15/05/2007
    13252/02 Dželadinov, judgment of 10/04/2008, final on 10/07/2008
    69875/01 Sulejmanov, judgment of 24/04/2008, final on 24/07/2008
    13191/02 Trajkoski, judgment of 07/02/2008, final on 07/07/2008

    10649/03 Fetaovski, judgment of 19/06/2008, final on 19/09/2008

    - Case of length of criminal proceedings
    26541/02 Nankov, judgment of 29/11/2007, final on 02/06/2008

    6906/03 Jankulovski, judgment of 03/07/2008, final on 03/10/2008

      - Cases of length of proceedings concerning civil rights and obligations before labour or civil courts and lack of an effective domestic remedy

    13886/02 Atanasovic and others, judgment of 22/12/05, final on 12/04/2006
    44208/02 Arsov, judgment of 19/10/2006, final on 19/01/2007
    13270/02 Dika, judgment of 31/05/2007, final on 12/11/2007
    14260/03 Gjozev, judgment of 19/06/2008, final on 19/09/2008
    6924/03 Graberska, judgment of 14/06/2007, final on 14/09/2007
    10541/03 Ivanovska, judgment of 15/11/2007, final on 31/03/2008
    44353/02 Kostovska, judgment of 15/06/06, final on 15/09/2006
    22931/03 Lazarevska, judgment of 05/07/2007, final on 10/12/2007
    38202/02 Lickov, judgment of 28/09/2006, final on 28/12/2006
    22742/02 Manevski, judgment of 19/06/2008, final on 01/12/2008
    22928/03 Markoski, judgment of 02/11/2006, final on 12/02/2007
    44221/02 Mihajloski, judgment of 31/05/2007, final on 31/08/2007
    15056/02 Milošević, judgment of 20/04/06, final on 20/07/2006
    26124/02 MZT Learnica A.D., judgment of 30/11/06, final on 28/02/20007
    14258/03 Parizov, judgment of 07/02/2008, final on 07/05/2008
    41228/02 Rizova, judgment of 06/07/06, final on 06/10/2006
    14349/03 Sali, judgment of 05/07/2007, final on 05/10/2007
    34215/02 Stojanov, judgment of 31/05/2007, final on 31/08/2007
    14818/02 Stojkovic, judgment of 08/11/2007, final on 02/06/2008
    27866/02 Ziberi, judgment of 05/07/2007, final on 05/10/2007

    - 7 cases against Turkey

    8932/03 Paşaoğlu, judgment of 08/07/2008, final on 08/10/2008

    23018/04+ Urcan and others, judgment of 17/07/2008, final on 17/10/2008

    16110/03 Karataş Şahin, judgment of 17/06/2008, final on 17/09/2008

    16330/02 Gülmez, judgment of 20/05/2008, final on 29/09/2008

    68514/01 Yılmaz and Kılıç, judgment of 17/07/2008, final on 17/10/2008

    12863/02 Işıldak, judgment of 30/09/2008, final on 30/12/2008

    14340/05 Fener Rum Patrikliği (Patriarcat œcuménique), judgment of 08/07/2008, final on 08/10/2008

    - 2 cases against Ukraine

    34056/02 Gongadze, judgment of 08/11/2005, final on 08/02/2006
    Interim Resolution CM/ResDH(2008)35

    3236/03 Ponomaryov, judgment of 03/04/2008, final on 29/09/2008

    - 1 case against the United Kingdom

    58243/00 Liberty and others, judgment of 01/07/2008, final on 01/10/2008

    SUB-SECTION 4.3 – SPECIAL PROBLEMS

    - 259 cases against Turkey

    - 190 cases concerning the actions of the Turkish security forces
    (Interim Resolutions ResDH(2005)43 and CM/ResDH(2008)69)
    CM/Inf/DH(2006)24
    (See Appendix for the list of cases in the Aksoy group)

    - 69 Friendly settlements and striking-out concerning actions of the Turkish security forces and involving undertakings by the Turkish government
    (See Appendix for the list of cases in the Aksoy group)

    SECTION 5 - SUPERVISION OF GENERAL MEASURES ALREADY ANNOUNCED

    (See Addendum 5 for part or all these cases)

    Action

    The Deputies are invited to supervise progress in the adoption of general measures aiming at preventing further similar violations to those found by the Court in the following cases. If necessary, supplementary information on some or all the cases listed below will appear in Addendum 5. The Deputies are invited to resume consideration of these cases in 6 months at the latest.

    SUB-SECTION 5.1 – LEGISLATIVE AND/OR REGULATORY CHANGES

    No new case

    SUB-SECTION 5.2 – CHANGES OF COURTS’ CASE-LAW OR OF ADMINISTRATIVE PRACTICE

    No new case

    SUB-SECTION 5.3 – PUBLICATION / DISSEMINATION

    The Deputies decided to resume consideration of these items at their 1072nd meeting (1-3 and 4 (morning) December 2009) (DH), in the light of information to be provided on general measures, namely publication and dissemination of the European Court's judgments.

    Section 5.3a
    Cases in which supervision of measures concerning publications and disseminations has been taking place for less than a year

    No new case

    Section 5.3b
    Cases in which supervision of measures concerning publications and disseminations has been taking place for more than a year

    No new case

      SUB-SECTION 5.4 – OTHER MEASURES

    No new case

    SECTION 6 - CASES PRESENTED WITH A VIEW TO THE PREPARATION OF A DRAFT FINAL RESOLUTION
    (See Addendum 6 for part or all these cases)

    Action

    At the time of issuing the present annotated Agenda and Order of Business, the information available on the measures taken in these cases seemed to allow the preparation of draft resolutions putting an end to their examination by the Committee of Ministers (if necessary, supplementary information on some or all the cases listed below will appear in an Addendum 6).

    As regards the cases appearing in Section 6.1, the Deputies are invited to examine the new information available with a view to evaluating whether a draft final resolution can be prepared. As regards cases listed in Section 6.2, the Deputies are invited to note that the elaboration of a draft final resolution, in co-operation with the delegation of the respondent state, is under way. In both cases, the Deputies are invited to postpone consideration of these cases to their next meeting.

    Section 6.1
    Cases in which the new information available since the last examination appears to allow the preparation of a draft final resolution

    - 5 cases against France

    75699/01 Vaturi, judgment of 13/04/2006, final on 13/07/2006
    17902/02 Zentar, judgment of 13/04/2006, final on 13/07/2006

    75833/01 Schemkamper, judgment of 18/10/2005, final on 18/01/2006

    38208/03+ Seris, judgment of 10/05/2007, final on 10/08/2007

    21324/02 Plasse-Bauer, judgment of 28/02/2006, final on 28/05/2006

    Section 6.2
    Cases waiting for the presentation of a draft final resolution

    No new case

1 This document has been classified restricted at the date of issue. Unless the Committee of Ministers decides otherwise, it will be declassified according to the rules set out in Resolution Res(2001)6 on access to Council of Europe documents.

2 Inclusion of cases in this Section does not exclude the possibility that general measures may be examined at subsequent meetings.


 Top

 

  Related Documents
 
   Meetings
 
   Other documents