Ministers’ Deputies
Annotated Agenda

CM/Del/OJ/DH(2007)992 Addendum 4 23 March 20071
———————————————

992nd (DH) meeting, 3-4 April 2007

Section 4

Cases raising special questions (individual measures, measures not yet defined or special problems)

——————————————

Action
Section 4

The Deputies are invited to resume consideration of the cases listed below, on the basis of the Rules concerning the application of Article 46, paragraph 2, of the Convention.

SUB-SECTION 4.2 – INDIVIDUAL MEASURES AND/OR GENERAL PROBLEMS

- 58 cases of freedom of expression
Interim Resolutions ResDH(2001)106 and ResDH(2004)38, CM/Inf/DH(2003)43

INDIVIDUAL MEASURES

Out-
standing problems

Application number

Name

Date of conviction

Ground for conviction

Date of erasure from criminal records

Other violations of the Convention

JS

34520/97

Alınak and others, judgment of 04/05/2006, final on 04/08/20062

11/04/96

Art. 8 anti-terror law

Convictions erased

Art. 6 § (1)
(military judge)

GM

42435/98

Aydın Abdullah, judgment of 09/03/2004, final on 09/06/2004

21/10/97

Art. 312 (2) Criminal Code

Conviction art. 312/ erased on unspecified date

Art. 6 § (1)
(military judge)

GM

45585/99

Ayhan No. 1, judgment of 10/11/2004, final on 06/06/2005

22/10/96 (art. 312)
28/12/95 (art. 8)
28/10/96 (art. 7 & 8)

Art. 312 Criminal Code / former Art. 8 anti-terror law / 7.2 anti-terror law + former Art. 8 anti-terror law

Conviction erased

Art. 6 § (1)
(military judge) Art. 6 § (1)

IM + GM

54916/00

Bakır, judgment of 25/10/2005, final on 25/01/2006

29/09/98

Art. 312 Criminal Code

 

Art. 6§1
(military judge)

GM

48988/99

Baran, judgment of 10/11/2004, final on 10/02/2005

07/08/98

Art. 312 (2) Criminal Code

20/05/2003

Art. 6 § (1)
(military judge)

GM

44104/98

Birol, judgment of 01/03/2005, final on 01/06/2005

26/06/97

Art. 159 (1) Criminal Code

Conviction erased

(not applicable)

GM

27214/95

C.S.Y., judgment of 04/03/03, final on 04/06/03

01/12/95

Art. 312 (2) Criminal Code & Art. 8 (1) anti-terror law

(not applicable)

(not applicable)

IM+ GM

71978/01

Çapan, judgment of 25/07/2006, final on 25/10/2006

8/11/2000

Art. 6 and 8 anti-terror law

 

Art. 6 § 1 (non-communication of opinion of public prosecutor)

IM + GM

64609/01

Çamlıbel, judgment of 22/12/2005, final on 22/03/2006

13/04/00

Art. 312 (2) Criminal Code

 

(not applicable)

GM

42779/98

Çetin Vedat, judgment of 20/12/2005, final on 20/03/2006

Judgment suspended 24/10/97 – dropped 10/09/01

Art. 312 (2) Criminal Code

(not applicable)

(not applicable)

GM

46454/99

Ceylan No. 2, judgment of 11/10/2005, final on 11/01/2006

10/03/98

Art. 312 (1)-(2) Criminal Code

Conviction erased

Art. 6 § (1)
(military judge)

GM

23556/94

Ceylan, judgment of 08/07/99

03/05/93

Art. 312 (1)-(2) Criminal Code

December 2003 (the proceedings instituted upon the applicant’s request for reopening ended on 27/04/2004 with his acquittal)

(not applicable)

Out-
standing problems

Application number

Name

Date of conviction

Ground for conviction

Date of erasure from criminal records

Other violations of the Convention

GM

46733/99

Dicle No. 2, judgment of 11/04/2006, final on 11/07/2006

19/11/98 (suspended)

Art. 312 (2) Criminal Code

Conviction erased 30/05/03

(not applicable)

GM

34685/97

Dicle, judgment of 10/11/2004, final on 10/02/2005

03/04/96

Art. 312 (1)-(2) Criminal Code

Conviction erased

Art. 6 § (1)
(military judge)

IM + GM

71984/01

Doğan Halis No. 2, judgment of 25/07/2006, final on 25/10/2006

08/11/2000 and 26/09/2000

Art. 6 and 8 anti-terror law

 

Art. 6 § 1 (non-communication of opinion of public prosecutor)

GM

59405/00

Erbakan, judgment of 06/07/06, final on 06/10/06

10/03/00
(05/07/00)

Article 312 Criminal Code

27/04/05

Art. 6§1
(military judge)

JS

25723/94

Erdoğdu, judgment of 15/06/003

20/12/93

re-examined:
18/04/96
10/12/97

Art. 8 (1)-(2) anti-terror law

Conviction erased

(not applicable)

GM

50273/99

Ergin and Keskin No. 1, judgment of 16/06/05, final on 16/09/05

30/06/98

Art. 312 Criminal Code; Art. 6 anti-terror law

Conviction erased

Art. 6 § (1)
(military judge)

GM

63926/00

Ergin and Keskin No. 2, judgment of 16/06/05, final on 16/09/05

16/04/98

Art. 6 anti-terror law

Conviction erased

Art. 6 § (1)
(military judge)

IM + GM

48944/99

Ergin Ahmet No. 1, judgment of 16/06/05, final on 16/09/05

08/09/98

Art. 312 Criminal Code

 

Art. 6 § (1)
(military judge)

GM

49566/99

Ergin Ahmet No. 2, judgment of 16/06/05, final on 16/09/05

05/11/98

Art. 312 Criminal Code

Conviction erased

Art. 6 § (1)
(military judge)

GM

50691/99

Ergin Ahmet No. 3, judgment of 16/06/05, final on 16/09/05

25/12/98

Art. 312 Criminal Code

Conviction erased

Art. 6 § (1)
(military judge)

GM

63733/99

Ergin Ahmet No. 4, judgment of 16/06/05, final on 16/09/05

14/04/98

Art. 312 Criminal Code

Conviction erased

Art. 6 § (1)
(military judge)

GM

63925/00

Ergin Ahmet No. 5, judgment of 16/06/05, final on 16/09/05

14/10/98

Art. 312 Criminal Code

Conviction erased

Art. 6 § (1)
(military judge)

GM

47796/99

Erol Ali No. 2, judgment of 27/10/2005, final on 27/01/2006

09/05/96

Art. 312 Criminal Code, Art. 155 Criminal Code

(not applicable)

(not applicable)

GM

77365/01

Falakaoğlu, judgment of 26/04/2005, final on 26/07/2005

03/10/02

Art. 312 (2) Criminal Code

Conviction erased

(not applicable)

GM

27215/95+

Gökçeli Yaşar Kemal, judgment of 04/03/03, final on 04/06/03

07/03/96

Art. 312 (2) Criminal Code

18/02/2004

(not applicable)

GM

40303/98

Gümüş and others, judgment of 15/03/2005, final on 15/06/2005

24/02/97

Art. 312 Criminal Code

Conviction erased

Art. 6 § (1)
(military judge)

GM

35071/97

Gündüz Müslüm, judgment of 04/12/2003, final on 14/06/2004

01/04/96

Art. 312 (2)-(3) Criminal Code

Conviction erased

(not applicable)

IM + GM

65849/01

Güzel No. 2, judgment of 27/07/2006, final on 27/10/2006

27/01/2000

Art. 312 Criminal Code

 

Art. 6 § 1 (non-communication of opinion of public prosecutor)

GM

30007/96

Halis, judgment of 11/01/2004, final on 11/04/2005

20/03/95
execution suspended:
25/07/02

Art. 7 (2) former anti-terror law

Conviction erased

Art. 6 § (1)
(military judge)

Out-
standing problems

Application number

Name

Date of conviction

Ground for conviction

Date of erasure from criminal records

Other violations of the Convention

GM

42920/98

Haydar Yıldırım and others, judgment of 15/07/2004, final on 15/10/2004

21/10/97

(3 req) Art. 312 Criminal Code

Convictions erased

Art. 6 § (1)
(military judge)

GM

22678/93

Inçal, judgment of 09/06/98

09/02/93

Art. 312 (2)-(3) Criminal Code and Art. 5 of former anti-terror law and Art. 4 of Press Act

25/03/2003

Art. 6 § (1)
(military judge)

GM

31236/96

Kalın, judgment of 10/11/2004, final on 10/02/2005

Re. the first article: 14/10/93
Re. the second article:
17/09/93

Art. 312 Criminal Code – re. the first article;
Art. 6 (2) anti-terror law – re. his second article

Conviction erased

Art. 6 § (1)
(military judge)

GM

33179/96

Karataş Seher, judgment of 09/07/02, final on 09/10/02

13/07/95

Art. 312 (1)-(2) Criminal Code

04/09/2003

Art. 6 § (1)
(military judge)

GM

43928/98

Karkin, judgment of 23/09/03, final on 23/12/03

22/10/97

Art. 312 (2) Criminal Code

Conviction erased at unspecified date

Art. 6 § (1)
(military judge)

IM + GM

48387/99

Kaya Haydar, judgment of 08/11/2005, final on 08/02/2006

24/11/97

Art. 312 Criminal Code

 

Art. 6§1
(military judge)

JS

27528/95

Kızılyaprak, judgment of 02/10/03, final on 02/01/044

14/10/93
re-examined:
16/02/96
suspended:
28/04/98

Art. 8 anti-terror law

02/12/2003

Art. 6 § (1)
(military judge)

GM

50934/99

Koç and Tambaş, judgment of 21/03/06, final on 21/06/06

22/06/99 (suspended)

Art. 8 anti-terror law, Art. 6 anti-terror law

Convictions erased 6/06/03

(not applicable)

IM + GM

40987/98

Korkmaz No. 1, judgment of 20/12/2005, final on 20/03/2006

25/02/97

Art. 6 (2) anti-terror law

 

Art. 6§1
(military judge)

IM + GM

42589/98

Korkmaz No. 2, judgment of 20/12/2005, final on 20/03/2006

28/05/97

Art. 6 (1) anti-terror law

 

Art. 6§1
(military judge)

IM + GM

42590/98

Korkmaz No. 3, judgment of 20/12/2005, final on 20/03/2006

18/04/96

Art. 6 (2) anti-terror law

 

Art. 6§1
(military judge)

GM

43996/98

Kürkçü, judgment of 27/07/2004, final on 27/10/2004

14/03/97

Art. 159 (1) Criminal Code

Conviction erased

(not applicable)

GM

41618/98

Odabaşı, judgment of 10/11/2004, final on 10/02/2005

01/12/97

Art. 312 (2) Criminal Code

Conviction erased

Art. 6 § (1)
(military judge)

Out-
standing problems

Application number

Name

Date of conviction

Ground for conviction

Date of erasure from criminal records

Other violations of the Convention

GM

23144/93

Özgür Gündem, judgment of 16/03/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2001)106

21 judicial decision
one of them dated: 12/12/96

Art. 159 Criminal code / Art. 312 Criminal Code / Art. 6 anti-terror law / former Art. 8 anti-terror law

(not applicable)

(not applicable)

GM

42119/98

Özkaya, judgment of 30/11/2004, final on 28/02/2005

17/09/97

Art. 312 (2) Criminal Code (+ 169 après arrêt)

Conviction erased

Art. 6 § (1)
(military judge)

GM

24914/94

Öztürk Ayşe, judgment of 15/10/02, final on 15/01/03

24/07/95 (312)
07/05/96 (8)

Art. 312 (2)-(3) Criminal Code & Art. 2 (1) of Press Act / former Art. 8 anti-terror law / former Art. 8 anti-terror law

18/02/03 (312)
29/01/03 (8)

(not applicable)

GM

29365/95

Öztürk Ünsal, judgment of 4/10/2005, final on 04/01/2006

Different dates

Art. 8 anti-terror law, Art. 7§2, 7§5 of anti-terror law; Art. 268 Criminal Code

Conviction erased

Art. 7

GM

22479/93

Öztürk, judgment of 28/09/99

30/03/89

Art. 312 Criminal Code

19/03/2003

(not applicable)

GM

39708/98

Pamak, judgment of 7/06/05, final on 7/09/05

01/11/96

Art. 312 Criminal Code

Conviction erased

Art. 6 § (1)
(military judge)

IM + GM

42605/98

Şahin Fikret, judgment of 06/12/2005, final on 06/03/2006

21/10/97

Art. 312 Criminal Code

 

Art. 6§1
(military judge)

GM

23927/94+

Sürek and Özdemir, judgment of 08/07/99

27/05/93

Art. 6 anti-terror law + Art. 8 anti-terror law (S) / Art. 6 anti-terror law + Art. 8 anti-terror law (O)

Convictions erased (both)

Art. 6 § (1)
(military judge)

GM

24122/94

Sürek No. 2, judgment of 08/07/99

02/09/93

Art. 6 anti-terror law

Conviction 6.1 AT law of 2/9/93 erased on 30/10/03

Art. 6 § (1)
(military judge)

GM

53648/00

Turhan Veysel, judgment of 20/09/2005, final on 20/12/2005, rectified on 6/12/2005

20/04/99

Art. 312 Criminal Code

Conviction erased

(not applicable)

JS + GM

57299/00

Varlı and others, judgment of 27/04/2006, final on 27/07/2006

08/02/99

Art. 312 Criminal Code

Convication erased

Art. 6 § (1)
(military judge)

JS + MG

62230/00

Yılmaz Sevgi, judgment of 11/04/2006, final on 11/07/2006

01/12/099

Art. 312 Criminal Code

25/10/2005

(not applicable)

GM

56362/00

Yüksel (Geyik), judgment of 25/10/2005, final on 25/01/2006

05/10/98

Art. 312 Criminal Code

Conviction eased

Art. 6§1
(military judge)

JS

25143/94+

Yurttaş, judgment of 27/05/04

12/04/96

Art. 8 anti-terror law

03/11/2003

Art. 5 § (3)

Friendly settlements concerning freedom of expression and involving undertakings by the Turkish government

Outstanding problems

Application number

Name

Date of conviction

Ground for conviction

Date of erasure from criminal records

 

GM

32985/96

Altan, judgment of 14/05/02 - Friendly settlement

18/10/95

Art. 312 Criminal Code

Conviction erased

 

GM

37048/97

Demirtaş Nurettin, judgment of 09/10/03 - Friendly settlement

03/02/95

19/07/96

Art. 159 Criminal code

Conviction erased

 

GM

37721/97

Erkanlı, judgment of 13/02/03 - Friendly settlement

22/09/95

Art. 159 Criminal code

Conviction erased

 

GM

35076/97

Erol Ali, judgment of 20/06/02 - Friendly settlement

04/04/96

Art. 312 Criminal Code

05/04/2004

 

GM

42436/98

Gerger No. 2, judgment of 09/03/04 - Friendly settlement

29/12/97

Art. 312 (2)-(3) Criminal Code

Conviction erased

 

GM

26976/95+

Sürek Kamil Tekin No. 5, judgment of 16/07/02 - Friendly settlement

19/07/94 (8)
05/07/94 (6)
02/09/93 (6)

Art. 8 anti-terror law
Art. 6 anti-terror law

31/07/2003 (8)
conviction (6) erased

 

GM

29910/96

Tanıyan, judgment of 17/03/2005 - Friendly settlement

Confis-cation orders

(Seizure)
Art. 312 Criminal Code
Prevention of Terrorism Act 1991

Conviction erased

 

IM + GM

51002/99+

Zana and others, judgment of 11/01/2005 - Friendly settlement

17/09/98

Art. 8 anti-terror law + Art. 312 Criminal Code

   

GM

32455/96

Zarakolu, judgment of 27/05/03 - Friendly settlement

28/09/95

Art. 7 anti-terror law

Applicant deceased

 


Legenda:


JS: the confirmation of payment of the just satisfaction is expected
IM: the confirmation of the adoption of appropriate individual measures is expected
GM: the confirmation of the adoption of appropriate general measures is expected

1 This document has been classified restricted at the date of issue. Unless the Committee of Ministers decides otherwise, it will be declassified according to the rules set up in Resolution Res(2001)6 on access to Council of Europe documents.

2 This case also appears in Section 3.a

3 This case also appears in Section 3.b

4 This case also appears in Section 3.a



 Top

 

  Related Documents
 
   Meetings
 
   Other documents