CASES No. 21

1108th meeting – 10 March 2011

- 387 cases against Ukraine

40450/04 YURIY NIKOLAYEVICH IVANOV, judgment of 15/10/2009, final on 15/01/2010

56848/00 ZHOVNER GROUP AND 385 OTHER CASES

CM/Inf/DH(2007)30rev and CM/Inf/DH(2007)33; DH-DD(2011)54

Interim Resolutions CM/ResDH(2008)1; CM/ResDH(2009)159; CM/ResDH(2010)222

Decision

The Deputies,

1. noted with satisfaction that a draft law addressing problems identified by the Court and providing a domestic remedy in cases of non-enforcement or unreasonably delayed enforcement of domestic judicial decision had been tabled before Parliament;

2. called upon the Ukrainian authorities to give priority to the adoption of the domestic remedy as required by the pilot judgment within the new deadline set by the Court, 15 July 2011;

3. stressed that in order to be considered as effective, such a remedy should meet the core requirements of the Convention, namely that:

- no-one should be required to prove the existence of non-pecuniary damage as it is strongly presumed to be the direct consequence of the violation itself;

- compensation should not be conditional on establishing fault on the part of officials or the authority concerned as the state is objectively liable under the Convention for its authorities’ failure to enforce court decisions delivered against them, within a reasonable time;

- the level of compensation must not be unreasonable in comparison with the awards made by the European Court in similar cases;

- adequate budgetary allocations should be provided so as to ensure that compensation is paid promptly;

4. urged the Ukrainian authorities to enhance their efforts to resolve the similar individual cases lodged with the Court before the delivery of the pilot judgment;

5. strongly urged all Ukrainian authorities to comply without further delay with their obligation under the Convention to enforce those domestic judgments in the cases which appear below in the appendix to the present decision.

Appendix to the decision in the case of Yuriy Nikolayevich Ivanov v. Ukraine and Zhovner group of cases

List of cases in which the domestic courts’ decisions remain unenforced notwithstanding the violations found in this respect by the Court

41073/02 Andrusenko and others, judgment of 10/11/2006, final on 10/02/2007

17022/02 Antonyuk, judgment of 11/12/2008, final on 11/03/2009

41803/04 Belochenko, judgment of 15/05/2008, final on 29/09/2008

25003/06 Biletskaya, judgment of 10/12/2009, final on 10/03/2010

35274/03 Blanutsa, judgment of 20/09/2007, final on 20/12/2007

34091/03 Borisov and others, judgment of 24/04/2008, final on 24/07/2008

39405/03 Chervonets (III), judgment of 24/04/2008, final on 24/07/2008

14394/04 Dedukh, judgment of 31/01/2008, final on 30/04/2008

35765/05+ Derevyanko and Beletskiy, judgment of 11/10/2007, final on 11/01/2008

19855/03 Donichenko, judgment of 05/04/2007, final on 05/07/2007

39265/02 Fateyev, judgment of 06/09/2007, final on 06/12/2007

12997/06 Filshteyn, judgment of 28/05/2009, final on 28/08/2009

71186/01 Fuklev, judgment of 07/07/2005, final on 30/11/2005

23906/05 Fyodorov, judgment of 22/07/2008, final on 22/10/2008

30675/06+ Gimadulina and others, judgment of 10/12/2009, final on 10/03/2010

19949/03 Glivuk, judgment of 20/09/2007, final on 20/12/2007

22358/06 Glushko, judgment of 15/10/2009, final on 15/01/2010

10398/04 Gogin, judgment of 11/12/2008, final on 11/03/2009

22215/04 Ivashchenko, judgment of 14/12/2006, final on 14/03/2007

1351/06+ Karpenko and Markov, judgment of 18/09/2008, final on 18/12/2008

45524/05+ Karpukhan and others, judgment of 10/12/2009, final on 10/03/2010

24739/05 Kharchuk, judgment of 12/06/2008, final on 12/09/2008

34419/06 Khmylyova, judgment of 18/06/2009, final on 18/09/2009

40753/07 Komnatskyy, judgment of 15/10/2009, final on 15/01/2010

20728/04 Kooperativ Kakhovskiy-5, judgment of 19/02/2009, final on 14/09/2009

1421/03+ Kopylovich and others, judgment of 17/01/2008, final on 17/04/2008

28808/07 Korniychuk, judgment of 15/10/2009, final on 15/01/2010

1110/02+ Koval and Patsyora, judgment of 03/05/2007, final on 03/08/2007

27349/03 Kozhanova, judgment of 22/11/2005, final on 22/02/2006

36772/04 Krasovskiy, judgment of 12/03/2009, final on 12/06/2009

19547/06 Krivenko, judgment of 15/10/2009, final on 15/01/2010

1811/06 Kryshchuk, judgment of 19/02/2009, final on 19/05/2009

26855/05 Lazarenko, judgment of 19/11/2009, final on 19/02/2010

4510/05 Logachova, judgment of 10/12/2009, final on 10/05/2010

903/05+ Lopatyuk and others, judgment of 17/01/2008, final on 17/04/2008

17327/02 Lukyanchenko, judgment of 15/05/2008, final on 15/08/2008

18219/02 Lysenko, judgment of 07/06/2007, final on 12/11/2007

11931/02 Mas, judgment of 11/01/2007, final on 23/05/2007

38683/04 Matkivska, judgment of 12/03/2009, final on 12/06/2009

32558/04 Mavrodiy, judgment of 07/06/2007, final on 07/09/2007

22986/04 Mikhaylov, judgment of 29/03/2007, final on 29/06/2007, rectified on 26/05/2008

42478/04 Mirvoda, judgment of 07/12/2006, final on 07/03/2006

5616/04 Omelchak, judgment of 15/05/2008, final on 15/08/2008

39924/02 Orel, judgment of 15/11/2007, final on 02/06/2008

8437/06+ Osokin and Osokina, judgment of 10/12/2009, final on 10/03/2010

1755/05+ Otychenko and Fedishchenko, judgment of 12/03/2009, final on 12/06/2009

5578/03 Ovcharenko, judgment of 22/11/2005, final on 22/02/2006

10911/05 Panchenko Ivan, judgment of 10/12/2009, final on 10/03/2010

22606/04+ Parintsev and others, judgment of 29/11/2007, final on 29/02/2008

37758/05 Peretyatko, judgment of 27/11/2008, final on 27/02/2009

12477/06+ Pidorina and Krylenko, judgment of 18/06/2009, final on 18/09/2009

25476/02 Pogrebna, judgment of 15/02/2007, final on 09/07/2007

48771/06 Prokopyeva, judgment of 30/07/2009, final on 30/10/2009

34126/05 Rotar, judgment of 15/10/2009, final on 15/01/2010

15879/06 Rukas, judgment of 15/10/2009, final on 15/01/2010

31449/04 Sakontseva, judgment of 12/06/2008, final on 12/09/2008

32166/04 Sarafanov, judgment of 14/12/2006, final on 14/03/2007

34168/05+ Savinskiy and Shevchenko, judgment of 19/11/2009, final on 19/02/2010

12868/05 Savula, judgment of 10/12/2009, final on 10/03/2010

9480/06 Semenovych, judgment of 30/07/2009, final on 30/10/2009

39846/04 Shaga, judgment of 31/01/2008, final on 30/04/2008

20028/04 Shapkina, judgment of 13/11/2008, final on 13/02/2009

10947/04 Shturkhalev, judgment of 24/04/2008, final on 24/07/2008, rectified on 01/09/2008

27589/05 Shventkovskiy, judgment of 30/07/2009, final on 30/10/2009

8107/06+ Skaloukhov and others, judgment of 19/11/2009, final on 19/02/2010

9177/05+ Skrypnyak and others, judgment of 10/07/2008, final on 10/10/2008

41152/98 Skubenko, judgment of 29/11/2005, final on 01/03/2006

8191/04 Solomatin, judgment of 15/10/2009, final on 15/01/2010

39760/05 Solonskiy, judgment of 30/07/2009, final on 30/10/2009

41313/06+ Sorokina and Goncharenko, judgment of 30/07/2009, final on 30/10/2009

30922/05 Stadnyuk, judgment of 27/11/2008, final on 27/02/2009

20984/04 Stankovskaya, judgment of 11/12/2008, final on 11/03/2009, rectified on 17/02/2009

2387/06 Storozhuk, judgment of 15/10/2009, final on 15/01/2010

5082/05 Sudyin, judgment of 24/04/2008, final on 24/07/2008

31387/05 Vasilchuk, judgment of 10/12/2009, final on 10/05/2010

39876/05+ Vasylyeva and others, judgment of 12/03/2009, final on 12/06/2009

39874/05 Voskoboynyk, judgment of 12/03/2009, final on 12/06/2009

14077/05 Yangolenko, judgment of 10/12/2009, final on 10/05/2010



 Top

 

  Related Documents
 
   Meetings